Rev. Johann Michael Gottlieb Schaller, 1850 – 1854
Rev. Carl Johann Herman Fick, 1854 – 1859
Rev. Johannes Nikolaus Adelbert Wuestemann, 1858 – 1859
Rev. Johannes Adam Heugli, 1860 – 1902
Rev. Herman Christian Friedrick Otte, 1902 – 1927
Rev. Dr. Gilbert Theodore Otte, 1927 – 1983
Rev. Dr. David Eberhard, 1983 – 2015
Rev. Darryl Lee Andrzejewski 2015 – Present
